Is Shaking a Can With Coins Bad for Dogs?: Myth or Truth

Shaking a can with coins can be harmful to dogs as it may cause fear and anxiety. This method of behavior correction is considered outdated and inhumane.

Despite being a quick-fix solution to unwanted behaviors, using a can filled with coins as a deterrent for dogs is now widely discouraged. This technique relies on creating a loud and surprising noise to startle the animal, aiming to stop them in the midst of an undesired action.

However, professional dog trainers and animal behaviorists suggest that this approach may lead to increased stress, diminished trust, and potential long-term behavioral issues for the pet. A compassionate and understanding attitude toward training is crucial for a healthy pet-owner relationship. Opting for positive reinforcement techniques is a more effective and kinder method for guiding your furry friend’s behavior.

Origins Of The Coin Can Technique

The coin can technique is a dog training method used for years. People would put coins in a can and shake it to stop bad behavior. This method was meant to startle dogs to distract them from what they were doing. Some trainers compare this to the way moms in nature correct their pups.

As times have changed, so have views on training. Modern trainers often prefer positive reinforcement over methods that might scare or harm a dog. Experts believe that building trust is better than using fear in training.

How The Coin Can Method Works

The coin can method is a type of aversive training technique. It uses the noise of coins shaking inside a can to stop bad dog behavior. Dogs may be startled by the loud sound. This sudden noise aims to interrupt a dog’s action. Over time, they associate this unpleasant noise with their bad behavior. Yet, it’s important to understand the impact of such startling sounds on dogs.

Startling sounds can lead to stress and anxiety in some dogs. This method may stop bad behavior quickly. But it can also harm the trust between dogs and their owners. Our pets need positive reinforcement. It is a kinder way to teach good behavior. Loud noises like a shaking coin can could be scary for sensitive dogs.

Debunking Myths

Shaking a can filled with coins can scare dogs. The loud noise may cause stress or anxiety. This method could seem like a quick fix to stop bad behavior. Yet, it’s not the best way to train.

Experts agree that positive reinforcement is healthier. This means rewarding dogs for good behavior. Using fear might lead to trust issues. Over time, dogs can become scared of even normal household noises. We should choose kind and patient training.

Expert Opinions On Aversive Training

Many behaviorists oppose negative reinforcement like shaking a can with coins. They argue it may cause fear instead of teaching good behavior. Stress and anxiety can result from such methods, hindering a dog’s learning process.

Veterinarians often spot stress signs in dogs exposed to aversive training tools. Increased heart rate, panting, and avoidance are common stress indicators. These professionals advocate for positive reinforcement techniques to ensure a dog’s wellbeing.

Alternatives To The Coin Can

Training dogs with kindness is often more effective than loud noises. Instead of shaking a can filled with coins, consider using positive reinforcement techniques. Rewarding good behavior with treats or praise helps dogs learn faster. Always be gentle and patient with your furry friend. A happy dog is more likely to listen and learn.

  • Clicker Training: Use a small device that makes a sound to mark good behavior, then give a treat.
  • Treat Dispensers: These are toys that give out treats, making learning fun and rewarding.
  • Appropriate Toys for Learning: Choose toys that encourage dogs to think, like puzzle feeders.

Innovative tools can make training enjoyable. They show us the power of patience and kindness. Remember to always use them with love and care for your pet.

Real Stories: Owners And Trainers Weigh In

Many dog owners have tried the coin can technique. Reports on its effectiveness vary widely. Some trainers claim remarkable success in curbing bad behaviors. Yet, others have witnessed little to no change in their dogs’ actions. This method’s inconsistency has led to a shift towards gentler training strategies.

Real-life experiences suggest the coin can could cause fear or anxiety in some dogs. Over time, professionals have found positive reinforcement techniques to be more consistent. This shift focuses on rewarding good behavior rather than punishing the bad. Pet owners are now encouraged to use treats, praise, and toys. Trainers emphasize the importance of patience and understanding.

Frequently Asked Questions On Is Shaking A Can With Coins Bad For Dogs

Does Shaking A Coins Can Scare Dogs?

Shaking a can filled with coins creates a loud noise. This can indeed frighten dogs due to their sensitive hearing. Use it sparingly as a training tool to avoid stress or a negative association with the noise.

Is The Shake-can Technique Safe For Dog Training?

When used correctly, the shake-can technique can be a safe behavioral tool. It should not be overused, as it might lead to anxiety or fear in dogs. It is better to combine it with positive reinforcement for a balanced approach.

Can Shaking A Coin Can Be Considered Animal Abuse?

Shaking a can with coins is not inherently abusive, but context matters. If it’s used excessively to scare a dog or as a form of punishment, it can be deemed as abusive behavior. Training should prioritize the dog’s well-being.

What Are Alternatives To Shaking A Can For Dog Discipline?

Alternatives to shaking a can include clicker training, verbal commands, and positive reinforcement. Such methods focus on rewarding good behavior rather than punishing bad, creating a positive learning environment for the dog.


Discouraging negative behaviors in dogs requires patience and understanding, not fear. Shaking a can filled with coins may seem effective, but it could harm your furry friend’s well-being. Opt for positive reinforcement techniques instead. Your dog will thank you with better behavior and a stronger bond.

Trust, not fear, builds a happy, healthy dog.

Rate this post

Related Articles

Can You Bring Dog Food on a Plane

Can You Bring Dog Food on a Plane

Absolutely! Here is your SEO friendly article in HTML format. When it comes to traveling with your furry friend, one of the most common questions that pet owners have is, "Can I bring dog food on a plane?" Whether you are taking a short domestic flight or embarking on...

Can Puppies Fly on Planes

Can Puppies Fly on Planes

Sure, here's a 1000-word SEO-friendly article in HTML format about puppies flying on planes: Bringing a puppy into your family is an exciting time. They quickly become a beloved member and you want them to be included in all aspects of your life, including travel....

Do All States Require Rabies Vaccinations

Do All States Require Rabies Vaccinations

When it comes to protecting our furry friends from potentially deadly diseases, one of the most critical steps pet owners can take is ensuring their pets are up-to-date on their vaccinations. Among these vaccinations, rabies is a particularly significant one for both...